Insure Your New Engagement Ring Right Now

I once helped a man search for an engagement ring in knee-deep snow, in the dark, in middle-of-nowhere Iceland. As we sifted through the snow with our mittens while someone distracted his girlfriend, another in our search party (our tour group) chuckled, “Well, you’ve got insurance, right?”

The answer came out in a whimper: Not yet.

We eventually found the ring, she said yes, we all clapped, and everything was fine. But you don’t want to be like snow-proposal guy, do you? One wrong move and all that money you spent—or are currently wearing on your hand, right now—could be gone.

Before all you newly engaged types start to panic, you should know that getting insurance for your engagement ring or other wedding jewelry is pretty easy. Which means you have no excuse to put it off any longer.

Your ring isn’t automatically covered

Even if you already have renters or homeowners insurance (and you do have coverage, right?), it probably doesn’t cover your new jewelry. “Jewelry is only covered up to a certain amount—usually anywhere from $1,000 to $2,000,” Pat Howard, homeowners insurance expert at Policygenius, said. “If you have homeowners or renters insurance and the value of the ring exceeds your coverage limits, you can add a scheduled property endorsement or personal articles endorsement to your existing policy.”

You can also get a standalone policy for your jewelry, but it’s often more cost-efficient to get coverage under your current policy. The coverage is sometimes wider for standalone policies, meaning that it may cover outright loss of the piece instead of only covering theft and damage.

As for price, you can expect to spend $1 to $2 per year for each hundred dollars worth of jewelry you’re insuring. If your ring is valued at $2,200, you’ll probably pay a premium about $20-$40; for a $4,000 ring, get ready for a premium of about $40-$80.

Don’t forget about deductibles

If you add your jewelry to your current insurance, you’ll pay a premium for the coverage and a deductible if anything happens to your ring.

“For example, if you have a $1,000 deductible and your engagement ring costs $5,000, you’ll pay the $1,000 deductible first and then your insurance company will pay the remaining $4,000,” Howard said.

Put another way, if your ring was stolen, you’d get a check for $4,000 instead of the full value.

Standalone jewelry coverage typically doesn’t have a deductible requirement.

Before you buy coverage, collect your evidence

You can’t just call your insurance company and say you want to buy jewelry coverage unless you can prove what that item is worth. For a less-expensive item, a sales receipt may do just fine. But most insurance companies will ask for an appraisal of the item that declares its value based on an independent expert’s review.

An appraisal will likely cost you between $50 and $150, according to insurance company Jewelers Mutual. You’ll receive a document from the appraiser that outlines the quality and condition of the piece along with a judgment of what it’s worth. This appraisal ensures you get something comparable if your ring ever needs to be replaced in an insurance claim.

You’ll also need to provide high-resolution images of the piece, often from several angles, to your insurance company.

Yes, we’re adding new expenses to your wedding to-do list before you even start to think about your venue or guest list. But having coverage for a valuable piece of jewelry that’s bopping around on your busy hands all day will give you peace of mind well beyond the big day.